by Bruce EderThis CD is a most satisfying listening experience, despite a few shortcomings in the packaging. Released under the auspices of Annie Haslam at a time when Renaissance had splintered in several different directions (with even Jane Relf reportedly getting ready to start using the group name again), it's assembled from what appear to be several live performances -- the notes by Haslam would lead one to believe that these date from the late '70s, and the line-up of Haslam, Michael Dunford, John Tout, Jon Camp, and Terry Sullivan. But as there are no dates or actual credits, that's impossible to say with 100% certainty -- what is true beyond doubt is that the sound is excellent (almost too good for a 70's-vintage concert recording) and the performances are superb from beginning to end; not only is the band tight and loud, but Haslam is in even better shape vocally than the rest of them are instrumentally. Indeed, fans of Jon Camp's bass work will especially love this CD, because his playing is way up front here without being obtrusive (just powerful).