After Dark found Andy Gibb beginning to run out of steam. The album was very similar stylistically to its predecessor, Shadow Dancing, but it didn't have as consistent a set of songs. Nevertheless, there were a number of fine moments on the record, including the singles "Desire" and "I Can't Help It," that made it worthwhile for dedicated fans, even if it was clear that Gibb's career would not be able to survive in the post-disco era.